July 12, 2012

NCAA cites Caltech's lack of control

Caltech hasn't had a lot of success in athletic competition. It turned out they didn't have a lot of success off the floor, either.
Caltech athletlcs photo

Caltech lacked institutional control when it allowed 30 ineligible student-athletes in 12 sports to practice or compete during four academic years, according to findings by the NCAA Division III Committee on Infractions. Penalties, including those self-imposed by Caltech, include three years probation, a postseason ban, a vacation of athletics records, and recruiting limitations.

The student-athletes were ineligible due in large part to Caltech’s unique academic policy that allows students to “shop” for courses during a three-week period of each quarter before finalizing their class schedules. During those three weeks, because they were not actually registered in some or all of the courses they are attending, some students were not technically enrolled on a full-time basis. Other student-athletes failed to meet good academic standing requirements.

This case was resolved through the summary disposition process, a cooperative effort where the involved parties collectively submit the case to the Committee on Infractions in written form. The NCAA enforcement staff, university and involved individuals must agree to the facts of the case in order for this process to be utilized instead of having a formal hearing.

The committee noted that Caltech’s failure to have procedures to verify the full-time enrollment status or academic standing of the student-athletes contributed significantly to the lack of institutional control. Caltech did not have a written process or procedure in place for performing certification duties and ensuring the eligibility of all student-athletes. The former director of athletics relied on the registrar’s office to communicate information to him, but he never formally requested the information and did not communicate NCAA eligibility requirements to personnel in that office. Further, the athletics department was not made aware when student-athletes were placed on academic probation or when student-athletes fell below good academic standing requirements. Similarly, coaches were not informed of the academic status of members of their teams.

A failure by Caltech to provide rules education to its coaches, student-athletes and administrators also contributed to the lack of institutional control. The only compliance and education activities on campus occurred at the beginning of each team’s season, when the former director of athletics distributed NCAA-mandated forms. Wendell Jack was athletic director prior to the 2010-11 season.

Caltech found the violations when the current director of athletics, Betsy Mitchell, recommended a review of academic records of all 2010-11 student-athletes. When the review revealed eight student-athletes competed while ineligible, Caltech expanded the review of records to previous years. The sports affected include: men’s water polo; men’s and women’s fencing; men’s soccer; men’s basketball; baseball; men’s tennis; women’s track and cross country; men’s track; and women’s swimming and diving.

The penalties include:

  • Public reprimand and censure.
  • Three years of probation from July 12, 2012, through July 11, 2015.
  • A 2012-13 postseason ban for men’s and women’s track and field; men’s and women’s cross country; women’s swimming; baseball; men’s and women’s fencing; men’s soccer; men’s water polo; men’s basketball; and men’s and women’s tennis. The ban extends to all the annual exemptions of Bylaw 17.1.4.5 and is further detailed in the public report. (Self-imposed by the university)
  • Vacation of all wins and individual records earned when ineligible student-athletes participated. (Self-imposed by the university)
  • A financial penalty of $5,000. (Self-imposed by the university)
  • Elimination of off-campus recruiting activities for the 2012-13 academic year. (Self-imposed by the university)

The NCAA release did not specify which contests included ineligible student-athletes. Caltech officials said the school's SCIAC 310-game streak-busting men's basketball win against Occidental was not affected.

The members of the Division III Committee on Infractions who reviewed this case include Keith R. Jacques, chair and attorney; Dave Cecil, director of financial aid at Transylvania; Amy Elizabeth Hackett, director of athletics at Puget Sound; and Nancy Meyer, director of women’s athletics at Calvin.

Apr. 22
MLAX:
Final
Mass.-Dartmouth 16, at Salem State 9
Box Box Box Box Box Recap
MLAX:
Final
at FDU-Florham 12, Manhattanville 4
Box
MLAX:
Final
Widener 8, at Lebanon Valley 6
Box
MLAX:
Final
at Eastern Connecticut 11, Western Connecticut 6
Box Box Box Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
MLAX:
Final
at Castleton State 19, Johnson State 1
Box Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
MLAX:
Final
at SUNY Canton 15, Wells 9
Recap
MLAX:
Final
at Mt. St. Mary (N.Y.) 16, Hartwick 15
Box
MLAX:
Final
at Elizabethtown 10, Hood 2
Box Box Recap
MLAX:
Final
Rosemont 10, at Bryn Athyn 3
Box Box Recap
MLAX:
Final
Medaille 18, at Alfred St. 6
Box Box Box Recap
MLAX:
Final - OT
Mass.-Boston 12, at Southern Maine 11
Box Box Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
MLAX:
Final
Keene State 18, at Plymouth State 10
Box Box Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
MLAX:
Final
at Keuka 19, SUNYIT 4
Box Box Box Box Recap
MLAX:
Final
Merchant Marine 14, at Mitchell 4
Box Box Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
MTEN:
8:00 PM
Thomas More at Mount St. Joseph
MTEN:
6:30 PM
Mt. St. Mary (N.Y.) at Bard
MTEN:
6:00 PM
Springfield at Hunter
MTEN:
Final
at John Jay 8, St. Josephs (Brkln) 1
Recap
MTEN:
Final
at Middlebury 8, Skidmore 1
MTEN:
4:30 PM
Suffolk CC at Farmingdale State
MTEN:
Final
at Roger Williams 5, Coast Guard 4
Recap
MTEN:
Final
Waynesburg 8, at Muskingum 1
Box Recap
MTEN:
Final
Rose-Hulman 8, at Centre 1
Box Recap
MTEN:
Final
at Haverford 8, Ursinus 1
Recap Recap
MTEN:
Final
Hope 7, at Calvin 2
Box Recap Recap
MTEN:
Final
Adrian 8, at Ohio Wesleyan 1
Box Recap
MTEN:
Final
Franklin and Marshall 5, at Gettysburg 1
Box Recap
MTEN:
Postponed
Hood at Elizabethtown
MTEN:
Final
Swarthmore 9, at Washington College 0
Recap
MTEN:
Final
at Hobart 8, Hamilton 1
MTEN:
Final
Nichols 9, at Wheaton (Mass.) 0
Box Recap
MTEN:
4:00 PM
Rosemont at Penn St.-Berks
MTEN:
Final
at Emory 9, Georgia Perimeter 0
MTEN:
Final
at Connecticut College 6, Babson 3
Box Recap
MTEN:
3:30 PM
Castleton State at Lyndon St.
MTEN:
3:30 PM
Rutgers-Newark at FDU-Florham
MTEN:
Final
at St. Olaf 9, Macalester 0
MTEN:
Final
St. Vincent 9, at Mt. Aloysius 0
MTEN:
Final
at Trine 6, Alma 3
Box Recap Recap
MTEN:
Cancelled
Md.-East. Shore at Stevenson
MTEN:
Final
at Northwestern (Minn.) 6, Martin Luther 3
MTEN:
Final
John Carroll 9, at Heidelberg 0
Box Recap
MTEN:
Final
at Penn St.-Abington 9, Baptist Bible (Pa.) 0
WLAX:
Final
at Saint Joseph's (Me.) 13, Johnson & Wales (RI) 8
Box Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
WLAX:
Final
Randolph-Macon 15, at Roanoke 13
Box Box Box Recap
WLAX:
Final
at Keuka 19, Wells 0
Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
WLAX:
Final
at Albion 21, Kalamazoo 5
Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
WLAX:
Final
at Gwynedd Mercy 20, Cedar Crest 11
Box
WLAX:
Final
TCNJ 17, at Richard Stockton 0
Box
WLAX:
Final
at Emmanuel (Mass.) 20, St. Joseph (Conn.) 8
Box Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
WLAX:
Final
at Norwich 11, Simmons 9
Box Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
WLAX:
Final
at Augustana 14, North Central (Ill.) 9
Box Box Box
WLAX:
Final
at Rowan 19, Rutgers-Camden 4
Box
WLAX:
Final
Roger Williams 8, at Keene State 6
Box Box Box Box Box Box Recap
WLAX:
Final - OT
at Benedictine (IL) 10, Aurora 9
Box
WLAX:
Final
at Calvin 15, St. Mary's (IN) 4
Box Box Box Recap
WLAX:
Final
at Hamilton 15, Ithaca 8
Box Box Box
WLAX:
Final
at Franciscan 16, Waynesburg 15
Box Box Recap
WLAX:
Final
Hope 20, at Trine 10
Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
WLAX:
Cancelled
Daniel Webster at Green Mountain
WLAX:
Final
Adrian 21, at Olivet 3
Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
WLAX:
Final
Christopher Newport 9, at St. Mary's (Md.) 8
Box Box Box Recap
WLAX:
Final
at Colby-Sawyer 18, Green Mountain 7
Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
WLAX:
Final
at Mary Washington 16, Marymount (Va.) 5
Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
WLAX:
Final
at Thomas 21, New England College 9
Box Box Box Box Recap
WLAX:
Final
at Centenary (N.J.) 20, St. Elizabeth 12
Box Box
WLAX:
Final
SUNY Geneseo 21, at Buffalo St. 10
Box Box Recap
WLAX:
Final
at Messiah 14, Stevenson 8
Box Box Recap
WLAX:
Final
at Kean 16, Ramapo 6
Box Box Recap
WLAX:
Final
Brockport State 13, at Fredonia State 5
Box
WLAX:
Final
at Cabrini 18, Rosemont 2
Box
WLAX:
Final
at Cortland State 18, Potsdam St. 5
Box
WLAX:
Final
Oswego St. 16, at New Paltz St. 10
Box
WLAX:
Final
Arcadia 18, at King's (Pa.) 5
Box Recap
WLAX:
Final
Rivier 11, at Lasell 7
Box Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
WLAX:
Final
Carthage 15, at Concordia (Wis.) 13
Box Box Box Recap
WTEN:
Cancelled
Agnes Scott at Oglethorpe
WTEN:
Final
at Muhlenberg 6, Swarthmore 3
WTEN:
4:00 PM
Virginia Union at Trinity (D.C.)
WTEN:
Postponed
St. Elizabeth at Bryn Athyn
WTEN:
Final
at MIT 8, Brandeis 1
Box Recap Recap
WTEN:
Final
Ohio Wesleyan 9, at Capital 0
Box Recap
WTEN:
Final
at McMurry 7, Hardin-Simmons 2
Recap
WTEN:
3:30 PM
Fairmont St. at Marietta
WTEN:
Final
Otterbein 8, at Mount Union 1
Recap
WTEN:
Final
Walsh 6, at Ohio Northern 3
Box Recap
WTEN:
5:00 PM
Stephens at Westminster (Mo.)
WTEN:
Final
Bethel (Minn.) 9, at Hamline 0
WTEN:
Final
Salisbury 7, at Christopher Newport 2
Recap
WTEN:
Cancelled
Md.-East. Shore at Stevenson
WTEN:
4:00 PM
Greenville at Lewis and Clark
WTEN:
Final
at Northwestern (Minn.) 9, Martin Luther 0
Apr. 21
MLAX:
Final - 2OT
at Elmhurst 7, Ill. Wesleyan 6
Box Box Recap
MLAX:
Final
Daniel Webster 20, at Green Mountain 9
Box Box Box Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
MLAX:
Final
New England College 18, at Thomas 2
Box Box Box Box Recap
MLAX:
Final
Transylvania 9, at Beloit 8
Box Box Recap
MTEN:
Final
at Suffolk 6, Anna Maria 1
Box Box Recap Recap
MTEN:
Final
at Allegheny 9, Penn St.-Behrend 0
Box
MTEN:
Final
at Goucher 8, Hood 1
Box Recap Recap
MTEN:
Final
at Rhode Island Col. 9, Thomas 0
Box Recap
MTEN:
Final
Rosemont 6, at Bryn Athyn 3
Recap
MTEN:
Final
at Roger Williams 6, Clark (Mass.) 3
Box Box Recap
MTEN:
Final
at Bethany (W.V.) 8, Muskingum 1
Box Recap
MTEN:
Final
Gordon 9, at Curry 0
Box Box Recap
MTEN:
Final
Oswego St. 8, at Keystone 1
MTEN:
3:30 PM
Brooklyn at Ramapo
MTEN:
Final
at Johnson & Wales (RI) 5, Mass.-Boston 4
Box Box Recap Recap
MTEN:
Final
Mt. St. Mary (N.Y.) 9, at Purchase State 0
MTEN:
Final
Regis (Mass.) 8, at Becker 1
Box Recap Recap
MTEN:
Final
at Brandeis 6, MIT 3
Box Recap Recap
MTEN:
Final
Western Connecticut 6, at Bridgewater State 3
Box Box Recap Recap
MTEN:
Final
at Claremont-Mudd-Scripps 8, Concordia (Cal.) 1
MTEN:
Final
Rose-Hulman 6, at Brescia 3
Box
MTEN:
Final
at Edgewood 6, Dubuque 3
Box
WLAX:
Final
Centre 21, at Transylvania 8
Box Box Box Recap
WLAX:
Final
at Fitchburg State 17, Wentworth 16
Box Box Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
WLAX:
Final
Worcester State 15, at Colby-Sawyer 4
Box Box Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
WLAX:
Final
Wheelock 19, at Bay Path 1
Box Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
WLAX:
Final
at Eastern 14, Elizabethtown 7
Box Box
WLAX:
Final
Mitchell 26, at Albertus Magnus 17
Box Box Box Box Box Box Recap Recap
WLAX:
Final
at Otterbein 18, Defiance 2
Box
WTEN:
Final
at Allegheny 9, Penn St.-Behrend 0
Box Recap
WTEN:
Final
at Webster 9, Fontbonne 0
WTEN:
Final
at Wooster 7, Baldwin Wallace 2
Box Recap Recap
WTEN:
Final
Gettysburg 9, at McDaniel 0
Box Recap
WTEN:
Final
Bridgewater State 7, at Colby-Sawyer 2
Box Recap Recap
WTEN:
Final
Emory 6, at Georgia Gwinnett 3
Recap
WTEN:
Final
at St. Olaf 9, Macalester 0
WTEN:
3:00 PM
Trinity (D.C.) at Lancaster Bible
© 2011, D3sports.com