Benedictine looking to D2

After finishing one win short of a Division III national championship in men's basketball in 2016, Keith Bunkenberg and the rest of the Eagles' athletic department are eyeing a move to Division II.
Benedictine athletics file photo

By staff

After announcing last April that it would explore a move to NCAA Division II, Benedictine University, in Lisle, Illinois, is poised to make that move. The university's board of trustees approved the school's application and the NCAA will now consider Benedictine's candidacy.

In April 2017 the university announced that it would explore the feasibility of changing its membership from Division III to Division II as part of the school's broader strategic plan. 

"This assessment provided a thorough study of the university’s ability to meet the requirements of Division II membership and demonstrated that the change would serve the University’s mission and its future goals," a Benedictine University official told The information was provided anonymously because the school does not currently have a university spokesperson in place. "The committee’s comprehensive study was examined through a diligent process and the recommendation to pursue Division II membership was approved by the university’s Board of Trustees.”

An institution must be sponsored by a confernce in order to apply for Division II membership. The Great Lakes Valley Conference, comprised of 15 schools ranging from Kenosha, Wisconsin, to Kansas City, Missouri, and Louisville, Kentucky, is sponsoring Benedictine's application.

Benedictine University has 2,733 full-time undergraduates, according to information it filed with the U.S. Department of Education in 2016.

"In Illinois, there are only four Division II schools including two that play football. There are only 32 Division II institutions in states surrounding Illinois including 22 that play football," the school's April 2017 announcement noted. "A move to Division II would increase Benedictine's regional and national uniqueness and visibility, and appeal to athletes seeking to play at a higher competitive level."

The school now awaits a decision from the NCAA Division II membership committee on their membership. If approved, Benedictine would become a provisional member of Division II and eventually transition to full membership. Applications to reclassify to Division II are due by Feb. 1, and Texas-Tyler, a Division III members of the American Southwest Conference, has also been mentioned as a school considering reclassification.

Benedictine is a member of the Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference for most sports except men's and women's lacrosse where its teams compete in the Midwest Lacrosse Conference and Midwest Women's Lacrosse Conference respectively. Benedictine was one of 12 schools in Illinois and Wisconsin to establish the NACC as charter members in 2006.

If Benedictine departs, the NACC would still be large enough to surpass the seven-member threshold and maintain its automatic qualifying bids to the NCAA playoffs in baseball, football and men's and women's basketball. Eureka joins the NACC for football in the fall of 2018, giving the NACC seven football-playing institutions without Benedictine.

While in transition, if approved, Benedictine would still play a Division III schedule in 2018-19, but not be eligible for the NCAA playoffs. The school could not offer athletic scholarships until 2019-20.

If Benedictine's membership in Division II is approved, the University will be the first Division III member to make that jump since Mississippi College did so in 2013. McMurry University in Abilene, Texas, also moved to Division II in 2012 and then returned to Division III and its prior conference, the American Southwest Conference, in 2014. Mississippi College's application for Division II was initially denied.

Contributing: Gordon Mann, Dave McHugh, Pat Coleman

More news from

  • Seeking a level playing field
    January 26, 2018
    While Title IX increased opportunities for women to play college sports, there are actually fewer women's head coaches in college now than before the law passed. Why is that and what can be done to level the playing field for women in the coaching profession? Ryan Scott explores in Around the Nation on
  • Who is Claire Marburger?
    January 19, 2018
    If you follow the IIAC, you might know her as Luther's All-American who transferred from Central. There is a lot more to her story that you probably don't know, including her battle with clinical depression. Claire has decided to tell that story to help others going through the same struggle. More on
  • Benedictine looking to D2
    January 16, 2018
    Having gained approval from its board of trustees, and found a sponsoring conference in Division II, Benedictine has made its application and will await word from the Division II membership committee.
  • Transfers on the move to find their groove
    January 12, 2018
    Choosing a college is one of the most important decisions in a person's life. What happens when that first choice ends up not being the best fit for academic, athletic or other reasons? Ryan Scott shares the stories of some Division III basketball transfer athletes who have found a home in new places.
  • The secret to coaching success
    December 11, 2017
    What does it take to be a successful coach? Good players, of course. And preparation. And all the things you hear about in postgame news conferences. But what about trust, flexibility and consistency? Why are coaching's "soft skills" so hard?'s Ryan Scott talked to some of the best in the business to find out.
  • Middlebury back on top in field hockey
    November 24, 2017
    For the second time in three seasons, and the third time overall, Middlebury won the Division III field hockey title, defeating Messiah in record fashion.
  • CMS wins first volleyball title, in sweep
    November 21, 2017
    The Claremont-Mudd-Scripps women's volleyball team brought the program's first national title in any women's sport back to campus, sweeping past Wittenberg in three sets.
  • Cru's success is infectious
    November 02, 2017
    Mary Hardin-Baylor's 2016 national title may well have lit a fire under the rest of the Crusaders' fall sports, with the volleyball and both soccer teams having great seasons. Meanwhile, the 2017 football Cru are looking to keep the run going. More on
  • Wash U goalie named NCAA Woman of the Year
    October 23, 2017
    Lizzy Crist, a Washington University in St. Louis graduate, became the fifth Division III student-athlete to win the highest individual honor the NCAA awards a student-athlete.
  • D-III's No. 1 takes down D-II's No. 1
    October 11, 2017
    Messiah, the defending national champion in field hockey, took it to Division II top-ranked Shippensburg, thrashing the defending Division II champ, 4-0.
  • From refugee to survivor, Achol Odolla is running free
    September 28, 2017
    Achol Odolla nearly died in the genocide in Ethiopia in 2003 and her family was soon on the run for their lives. Coming to the U.S. as a refugee gave her a new lease on life, but meanwhile, she's still running, on the Stevenson women's cross country team. A #whyd3 story.
  • Record crowd sees Division III football game
    September 23, 2017
    St. Thomas defeated archrival for the fourth consecutive time and the seventh time in the past nine meetings, as the Tommies defeated St. John's 20-17 in front of more than 37,000 fans. Full coverage on
  • Division III alumni receive invites to NHL training camps
    September 13, 2017
    At least four former Division III players, including two players from Division III's Class of 2017, will have the opportunity to leave their mark at the highest level of professional hockey as invitees to 2017 NHL training camps.
  • CSAC restocks with two new schools
    September 08, 2017
    Over the summer, five schools announced they would be leaving the Colonial States Athletic Conference after the 2017-18 school year, leaving the conference with no schools that had ever won its all-sports title. But the CSAC is starting to patch the holes.
  • Division III gives the full college experience
    August 16, 2017
    Manchester sophomore women's cross-country runner Emily Lynn has made the most of her first year as a Division III student-athlete.
  • ODAC expands to add Ferrum
    June 27, 2017
    The Old Dominion Athletic Conference is adding another all-sports member, but perhaps most importantly, Ferrum brings with it an eighth football program.
  • A new conference shuffle coming
    June 06, 2017
    A decade ago, a Mid-Atlantic Shuffle created a new conference and remade six others. Now, the process looks ready to start again, with eight schools from three leagues in the process of signing on for another new group.
  • Thomas More to withdraw from PAC
    June 01, 2017
    After 12 years, Thomas More will be leaving the Presidents' Athletic Conference following the upcoming school year. And the school did not announce a new home.
  • Gettysburg women capture second lacrosse title
    May 29, 2017
    The Bullets scored the go-ahead goal with just under three minutes left and iced the game away, defeating TCNJ 6-5 to take home Walnut and Bronze in women's lacrosse.
  • Salisbury adds to trophy case
    May 29, 2017
    The Sea Gulls made it an even dozen men's lacrosse national titles, and they made it look easy with a 15-7 win vs. RIT.
  • Salisbury, RIT to meet for men's lacrosse title
    May 23, 2017
    No. 1 and No. 2 will meet for the title in Gillette Stadium in Foxborough, Mass., sporting a combined record of 41-3.
  • Baseball postseason opens
    May 18, 2017
    Over the course of five days, the Field of 56 in baseball get whittled down to the eight teams who will advance to the Division III World Series in Appleton, Wis. Follow all of the action on
  • Salisbury moves on; Lynchburg posts upset
    May 14, 2017
    The top-ranked Sea Gulls had no trouble with Hampden-Sydney, while Lynchburg posted a road win at York (Pa.) as the third round of the D-III men's lacrosse tournament wasn't much more competitive than the second.
  • Castleton to join Little East in 2018
    May 04, 2017
    The Little East, a collection of state schools in New England, is expanding to Vermont for the first time with the addition of Castleton for the 2018-19 academic year.
  • Illinois Tech finds home in NACC
    May 03, 2017
    The Illinois Tech athletic department should be full members of Division III in two years, and its baseball team will play in the WIAC next spring, but the following year, IIT will become full NACC members.
  • Westfield State pitching: A family affair
    May 03, 2017
    For the past 44 years, Westfield State University has been a family affair for the Sullivans, culminating with senior pitcher Julie Sullivan.
  • Springfield back on top in men's volleyball
    April 30, 2017
    The Pride avenged last year's loss to SUNY New Paltz, defeating the Hawks in four sets to win the NCAA Division III national title in men's volleyball for the fourth time in the six seasons it has been awarded.
  • No. 1 Bates men's lacrosse completes undefeated regular season
    April 26, 2017
    The No. 1 ranked Bates men's lacrosse team became the first team in NESCAC history to go 10-0 in league play with a 24-10 victory over Colby.
  • Kalamazoo extends streak to 79 years
    April 22, 2017
    If you thought Mount Union had a long football streak, or Kenyon had won a lot of swimming titles, you've got another thing coming. Meet the Kalamazoo men's tennis program.
  • Thayer racks up record 21 K's, adds perfect game
    April 22, 2017
    Seven innings multiplied by three outs equals 21, and while that's not the maximum number of strikeouts a pitcher could theoretically get in a fastpitch game, it is the record. On Friday, Lindsey Thayer tied it. On Saturday, she threw a perfect game.
Load More